Illustration of a large hairy beast walking in a dark wood
Gary Hanna

The Search for Bigfoot

For years, people have said that a giant lives in the forests of the West. Could it be true?

By Lauren Tarshis
From the February 2021 Issue

Learning Objective: Students will consider evidence in an article about the story of Bigfoot to promote critical thinking about whether something they read or hear should be believed or not.

Lexile: 600L-700L, 800L-900L
Guided Reading Level: U
DRA Level: 50
Download and Print
UP CLOSE

Text Evidence

As you read, look for reasons people have believed in Bigfoot and evidence showing that this creature doesn’t exist.

On a chilly February night in 1962, a man named Robert Hatfield was standing in his sister’s backyard in Fort Bragg, California. His sister’s dogs were howling, and Hatfield had rushed outside to see what was wrong. He stared out into the forest that surrounded the house. There was something out there in the darkness.

Something big.

Something wild.

And then there it was in the shadows—a giant creature, walking on two legs. A bear, Hatfield thought, the biggest bear he’d ever seen.

He ran inside to wake up his brother-in-law. The two men went back outside and started to search around the house. Hatfield was coming around the side of the house when, Bam! He crashed right into the bear.

Except it wasn’t a bear, Hatfield was sure.

“It was covered with fur with a flat, hairless face and perfectly round eyes,” Hatfield said. 

It was a chilly February night in 1962. A man named Robert Hatfield stood in his sister’s backyard in Fort Bragg, California. His sister’s dogs were howling. Hatfield had rushed outside to see what was wrong. He stared out into the forest that surrounded the house. There was something out there in the darkness.

Something big.

Something wild.

And then there it was in the shadows—a giant creature, walking on two legs. A bear, Hatfield thought, the biggest bear he’d ever seen.

He ran inside to wake up his brother-in-law. The two men went back outside and started to search around the house. Hatfield was coming around the side of the house when, Bam! He crashed right into the bear.

Except it wasn’t a bear, Hatfield was sure.

“It was covered with fur with a flat, hairless face and perfectly round eyes,” Hatfield said. 

Shutterstock.com

Hatfield and his brother-in-law ran away, and the mysterious beast disappeared into the darkness.

But the story quickly spread. A group of men later searched the woods. They found no trace of it—no footprints in the dirt, no clumps of fur clinging to trees. 

Still, some of the men were sure they knew what Hatfield had seen. For years people had been telling stories about a giant hairy creature lurking in the California woods. They called it Bigfoot.

Hatfield and his brother-in-law ran away, and the mysterious beast disappeared into the darkness.

But the story quickly spread. A group of men later searched the woods. They found no trace of the creature—no footprints in the dirt, no clumps of fur clinging to trees. 

Still, some of the men were sure they knew what Hatfield had seen. For years, people had been telling stories about a giant, hairy creature lurking in the California woods. They called it Bigfoot.

Ancient Stories

For as long as people have been exploring the dark forests of America’s West, they have been telling stories about giants that lurk in the shadows.

The first stories were legends belonging to different Native American tribes. The Muckleshoot people told of Slapu, a hairy female giant that snatched naughty children who wandered off alone. The Quinault people shared stories of giants that crept out of the woods to steal food and tools. The Sts’ailes people spoke of a giant they called sasq’ets, which means “hairy man” in their language.

These different legends were passed down through families and within communities. Like leaves picked up by the wind, these stories spread across the land. They reached outsiders, who turned them into stories of their own. This is likely how, in the early 1900s, the tale of Bigfoot began.

People have been exploring the dark forests of America’s West for a long time. They have been telling stories about giants in the shadows for a long time too.

The first stories were legends belonging to different Native American tribes. The Muckleshoot people told of Slapu. Slapu was a hairy female giant that took children who wandered off alone. The Quinault people shared stories of giants that stole food and tools. The Sts’ailes people spoke of a giant they called sasq’ets. The word sasq’ets means “hairy man” in their language.

These different legends were passed down through families. They were told within communities. Like leaves picked up by the wind, they spread across the land. They reached outsiders, who turned them into stories of their own. This is likely how, in the early 1900s, the tale of Bigfoot began.

The Humboldt Times

Bigfoot is Born

The Bigfoot story was likely first told by lumberjacks working in the forests of the West Coast. It was one of many tall tales men told around their campfires after long days of work. These were creepy stories, outrageous stories, stories old-timers told to scare younger men. They warned of a ferocious rhinoceros that lived in the forest, a creature called the hodag. They swore there were fist-sized mosquitoes that could suck the blood of a cow—or a man—in one slurp.

And then there was the giant Bigfoot stalking the woods.

Nobody really believed that such creatures were real. These stories were just for fun—everyone knew that. But then something changed. In 1958, in a Northern California forest, Bigfoot somehow started to come alive.

The Bigfoot story was likely first told by lumberjacks. These lumberjacks worked in the forests of the West Coast. It was one of many tall tales men told around their campfires after long days of work. These were creepy stories told by old-timers to scare younger men. They warned of a scary rhinoceros that lived in the forest. It was called the hodag. They also swore there were fist-sized mosquitoes. These mosquitoes could suck the blood of a cow or a man in one slurp.

And then there was the giant Bigfoot stalking the woods.

Nobody really believed that such creatures were real. These stories were just for fun. Everyone knew that. But then something changed. In 1958, in a Northern California forest, Bigfoot somehow started to come alive.

Enormous Footprints

It began with a set of footprints. All summer long, men had been noticing strange footprints around their worksite in the forest. The prints looked almost human, with a heel and five toes.

Except they were enormous.

Someone was playing a prank, the men agreed. Any minute the jokester would step forward for a big laugh. More footprints soon appeared, and rumors swirled.

Some claimed that strange things were happening in the woods.

“Did you hear about the four dogs that disappeared?”

“Did you hear that a 700-pound tire was found in a ditch?”

Some men claimed to hear chilling sounds in the night—rumbling growls, bone-chilling shrieks.

A few started carrying guns, just in case.

It began with a set of footprints. All summer long, men had been noticing strange footprints around their worksite in the forest. The prints looked almost human. They had a heel and five toes. But the prints were enormous.

The men agreed someone was playing a prank. Any minute the jokester would step forward for a big laugh. More footprints soon appeared. Rumors swirled.

Some claimed that strange things were happening in the woods.

“Did you hear about the four dogs that disappeared?”

“Did you hear that a 700-pound tire was found in a ditch?”

Some men claimed to hear chilling sounds in the night. They heard rumbling growls. They heard bone-chilling shrieks.

A few started carrying guns, just in case.

The Humboldt Times

A Big Clue

Andrew Genzoli and Jerry Crew study the cast of the giant footprint that Crew found.

16-Inch Tracks

And then, in September, a fresh set of footprints appeared. One of the workers, a man named Jerry Crew, studied them closely. Crew had heard the Bigfoot rumors, of course— everyone had. He had laughed them off like most of the others. But looking at the footprints in the mud, a chill went up his spine. This giant—Bigfoot—is out there, he decided.

Crew was known by his co-workers as serious and trustworthy. His opinion turned other men into believers. He also decided to share the news with people outside the forest.

And then, in September, a fresh set of footprints appeared. A man named Jerry Crew studied them closely. He was one of the workers. Crew had heard the Bigfoot rumors, of course. Everyone had. He had laughed them off like most of the others. But looking at the footprints in the mud, a chill went up his spine. This giant is out there, he decided.

Crew was known by his co-workers as serious and trustworthy. His opinion turned other men into believers. He decided to share the news with people outside the forest.

Shutterstock.com

Crew took a plaster cast of the footprint. He poured a cement-like goo into one of the footprints. When it dried, he could lift it out. Now he had a perfect copy of the footprint to prove what he was saying was true.

He showed it to a newspaper reporter named Andrew Genzoli, who wrote a story for one of the area’s newspapers, the Humboldt Times.

“Who is making the huge 16-inch tracks in the vicinity of Bluff Creek?” Genzoli wrote. “Are the tracks a human hoax? Or, are they the actual marks of a huge but harmless wild man, traveling through the wilderness?”

Crew took a plaster cast of the footprint. He poured a cement-like goo into one of the footprints. When it dried, he could lift it out. Now he had a perfect copy of the footprint. It would prove what he was saying was true.

He showed it to a newspaper reporter named Andrew Genzoli. Genzoli wrote a story for one of the area’s newspapers, the Humboldt Times.

“Who is making the huge 16-inch tracks near Bluff Creek?” Genzoli wrote. “Are the tracks a human hoax? Or are they the actual marks of a huge but harmless wild man? A wild man traveling through the wilderness?”

Looking for Proof

Genzoli would later say he wasn’t sure there really was a giant in the woods. He just thought his readers would get a kick out of the story. He was shocked when his article was picked up by hundreds of newspapers and magazines, including The New York Times. It caught the attention of people around the world. Soon, people from everywhere were asking: Is there a giant living in the woods of California?

In the coming years, fascination with Bigfoot grew and grew. Hundreds of people went into the forests, searching for clues. Sightings were reported in California and other Western states.

Many claimed to have seen footprints. Others brought back clumps of fur and scat (animal poop) they said must belong to Bigfoot.

Hundreds of people, including Robert Hatfield and his brother-in-law, swore they actually saw Bigfoot with their own eyes.

In 1967, two men claimed to have filmed Bigfoot walking along a creek in California. The image was blurry. But for some, this was the final proof they needed.

Yes! Bigfoot is real!

Genzoli would later say he wasn’t sure there really was a giant in the woods. He just thought his readers would get a kick out of the story. He was shocked when his article was picked up. It was in hundreds of newspapers and magazines, including The New York Times. It caught the attention of people around the world. Soon, people from everywhere were asking: Is there a giant living in the woods of California?

In the coming years, fascination with Bigfoot grew and grew. Hundreds of people went into the forests, searching for clues. Sightings were reported in California and other Western states.

Many claimed to have seen footprints. Others brought back clumps of fur and scat (animal poop). They said these items must belong to Bigfoot.

Hundreds of people, including Robert Hatfield and his brother-in-law, swore they actually saw Bigfoot with their own eyes.

In 1967, two men claimed to have filmed Bigfoot. He was walking along a creek in California. The image was blurry. But for some, this was the final proof they needed.

Yes! Bigfoot is real!

Bettmann/Getty Images

Caught On Camera?

The makers of this film claimed to have caught Bigfoot on camera. But most scientists today think it shows a person in a costume.

Fake Footprints

But no.

In fact, the film is so blurry it’s hard to know what is on the screen. Is it a hairy giant walking on two legs? Or is it a person in a gorilla costume? Most scientists and animal experts reject the film as a hoax. Other “evidence” doesn’t impress them either—not the footprints, the fur, or the scat people have seen.

They point out that many different large animals live in forests—bears, mountain lions, elk, moose. All leave behind their scat and clumps of fur. They make strange noises too. Female foxes—called vixens—let out earsplitting shrieks that sound scarier than any movie monster.

And Jerry Crew’s footprints? It turned out that they were fake. Years later, two brothers admitted to planting the footprints as a joke.

It’s been more than 60 years since Genzoli’s article ignited Bigfoot mania. Thousands of people have looked for the giant. And yet nobody has come up with clear evidence—a skeleton, an in-focus photograph, a clear video.

But no.

The film is blurry. It’s hard to know what is on the screen. Is it a hairy giant walking on two legs? Or is it a person in a gorilla costume? Most scientists and animal experts say the film is a hoax. Other “evidence” doesn’t impress them either. They are not impressed by the footprints, the fur, or the scat people have seen.

They point out that many different large animals live in forests. This includes bears, mountain lions, elk, and moose. All leave behind scat and clumps of fur. They make strange noises too. Female foxes let out earsplitting screams. They sound scarier than any movie monster.

And Jerry Crew’s footprints? It turned out that they were fake. Years later, two brothers admitted to planting the footprints as a joke.

It’s been more than 60 years since Genzoli’s article started Bigfoot madness. Thousands of people have looked for the giant. But nobody has come up with clear evidence. Nobody has a skeleton, an in-focus photograph, or a clear video.

Eric Isselee/Shutterstock.com

Legend to Real Life

No one outside Central Africa believed the okapi was real—until scientists saw evidence of one in the early 1900s.

Bigfoot Hunts

But even without hard proof, many still cling to the belief that Bigfoot is out there.

There are Bigfoot books and Bigfoot blogs, Bigfoot movies and Bigfoot TV series. Google “Bigfoot” and you’ll get more than 30 million hits. There are even “Bigfoot hunts,” with people paying hundreds of dollars to be guided through the woods with hopes of photographing the creature. According to a 2018 survey by Chapman University, 21 percent of Americans think that Bigfoot is a real creature.

But with no real proof, why do so many believe?

One reason could be that new species of animals are constantly being discovered. Scientists agree there are likely millions of species of plants and animals that have yet to be identified. They are hidden away in rainforests, fluttering or slinking behind curtains of trees. They thrive in the pitch blackness of the deep ocean, far from human eyes.

There is no proof. But many still believe that Bigfoot is out there. There are Bigfoot books and Bigfoot blogs. There are Bigfoot movies and Bigfoot TV series.

Google “Bigfoot.” You’ll get more than 30 million hits. There are even “Bigfoot hunts.” People pay hundreds of dollars. Then they are guided through the woods. They hope to take a picture of the creature. According to a 2018 survey by Chapman University, 21 percent of Americans think that Bigfoot is a real creature.

But with no real proof, why do so many believe?

One reason could be that new species of animals are constantly being discovered. Scientists agree there are likely millions of species of plants and animals that haven’t been found. They are hidden away in rainforests. They flutter or slink behind curtains of trees. They live in the pitch blackness of the deep ocean, far from human eyes.

John Bazemore/AP Images

To Believe or Not to Believe?

Today, thousands of Bigfoot photos and artifacts can be found at the Expedition: Bigfoot! museum in Georgia. Visitors are invited to explore and decide for themselves whether the tales are true.

Mythical Creatures

There have also been animals from legends and myths that turned out to be real. The giant squid is one. For centuries, sailors had come home with stories of a sea monster with a single dinner-plate-sized eye and strangling tentacles. They called it the Kraken. Few believed that this sea monster was real—until the late 1800s, when a giant tentacle washed up on a beach.

Another is an animal called the okapi, a beautiful donkey-sized animal with velvety striped fur. The okapi was well-known among people who lived in the forests of Central Africa. But it wasn’t until 1901 that outsiders and scientists accepted that this animal actually existed. It turns out to be a close relative of the giraffe.

As for Bigfoot, scientists agree it’s highly doubtful that such a giant creature could remain mostly hidden. Most reject the idea completely.

So why do some people continue searching? Maybe because there is something pleasing about the idea of Bigfoot. Nobody has ever said that this giant is dangerous. In most stories, he is described as shy and gentle, watching over the forests—and us.

It’s unlikely that Bigfoot is real. And if someone does prove that this gentle giant is out there? Maybe it would be best if we humans left him alone.


With additional reporting by Mackenzie Carro

There have also been animals from legends and myths that turned out to be real. The giant squid is one. For centuries, sailors had come home with stories of a sea monster. This monster had a single dinner-plate-sized eye and strangling tentacles. They called it the Kraken. Few believed that this sea monster was real. Then, in the late 1800s, a giant tentacle washed up on a beach.

Another is an animal called the okapi. An okapi is a beautiful donkey-sized animal with velvety striped fur. The okapi was well-known among people living in the forests of Central Africa. But it wasn’t until 1901 that outsiders and scientists accepted that this animal actually existed. It turns out to be a close relative of the giraffe.

As for Bigfoot, scientists think it’s unlikely that such a giant creature could remain mostly hidden. Most reject the idea completely.

So why do some people continue searching? Maybe because there is something pleasing about the idea of Bigfoot. Nobody has ever said that this giant is dangerous. In most stories, he is described as shy and gentle. He watches over the forests, and us.

It’s unlikely that Bigfoot is real. And if someone does prove that this gentle giant is out there? Maybe it would be best if we humans left him alone.

This article was originally published in the February 2021 issue.

This article was originally published in the February 2021 issue.

video (1)
Slideshows (2)
Slideshows (2)
Audio ()
Activities (10)
Quizzes (1)
Answer Key (1)
video (1)
Slideshows (2)
Slideshows (2)
Audio ()
Activities (10) Download All Activities
Quizzes (1)
Answer Key (1)
Can't-Miss Teaching Extras
Explore the Storyworks Archive

Pair this article with “Monster of the Deep” from our May/June 2019 issue. It delves into the story of the mythical Kraken that turned out to be the real giant squid.

More About the Story

Skills

text evidence, author’s craft, compare and contrast, inference, text structure, analyzing, critical thinking, author’s purpose

Complexity Factors

Levels of Meaning

The article informs students about what has made some people believe in a mysterious hulking creature called Bigfoot, and the stories that have circulated about him. On another level, it aims to provoke readers to think critically about what is true and how we use and evaluate evidence to decide what to believe.

Structure

The structure is mainly chronological. The end of the article discusses other creatures that were thought to be mythical but turned out to be real.

Language

The article contains some rhetorical questions and idioms (“get a kick out of,” “a chill went up his spine”). It also includes names of Native American tribes and a few words in their languages. Most of the vocabulary will be familiar to students, but it contains some challenging words, such as hoax and species.

Knowledge Demands 

No special knowledge is necessary.

Step-by-Step Lesson Plan

1. Preparing to Read

Engage Students, Watch a Video, Preview Vocabulary

  • Show students the picture of Bigfoot on pages 4-5. Take a quick class poll: Who thinks this creature is real? Who thinks it’s fake? Ask students to give evidence to support their answers.
  • Show or assign the video “Storyworks: Monster Myths” to prepare for reading. Students can complete the Video Discussion Questions (available in your Resources tab) on their own, in groups in your classroom, or in virtual breakout rooms.
  • Show or assign our special Vocabulary Slideshow. With this article, we have focused on terms related to discerning whether something should be believed. Is a story true? Is it just for fun, or could it be harmful? Highlighted terms: legends, tall tales, rumors, hoax, evidence

★ New for Remote Learners!

  • We created a Bigfoot Learning Journey Slide Deck that bundles the article, video, and close-reading questions together into a highly engaging learning journey.
  • Our Text Evidence Skill Builder is available as a slide deck specifically designed for students to do on their own. 

2. Reading and Discussing

  • Have students read the article in the magazine or digitally. They can also listen to the Author Read-Aloud, which now includes some additional questions and prompts from the author.
  • Put students in groups, either in your classroom or in virtual breakout rooms. Ask them to read the article a second time and discuss or write their answers to the close-reading questions and critical-thinking questions (available in your Resources tab).

Close-Reading Questions

  1. In the first section of the story, what makes Robert Hatfield think the creature he saw wasn’t a bear? What made people think Hatfield had seen Bigfoot? (text evidence) The creature Hatfield saw was enormous “with a flat, hairless face and perfectly round eyes.” People believed he had seen Bigfoot because stories of such a creature had been told for a long time, and Hatfield’s experience fit in with those stories.
  2. Reread “Ancient Stories.” Why does the author compare legends about a giant to “leaves picked up by the wind”? What does it tell you about how the Bigfoot story first started? (author’s craft) This comparison helps illustrate how stories and legends spread from community to community. The story of a giant in the woods likely spread from various Native American tribes to outsiders who again retold the story, this time with Bigfoot as the giant. 
  3. Compare the section “Bigfoot Is Born” with “Enormous Footprints.” How did people’s beliefs about Bigfoot change? Why? (compare and contrast) At first, stories about Bigfoot were told just for fun. But in 1958, “Bigfoot somehow started to come alive.” People started seeing footprints that couldn’t be explained, so they began to believe Bigfoot was real.
  4. In “16-Inch Tracks,” Jerry Crew is described as “serious and trustworthy.” How do you think this affected other people’s belief in Bigfoot? (inference) People probably thought that a “serious and trustworthy” person wouldn’t be easily fooled into believing something that’s not real. Since Crew was convinced that the huge footprint he saw came from Bigfoot, others also believed this.
  5. What “evidence” has made some people believe Bigfoot is real? How can these pieces of evidence be explained? (text evidence) One main piece of evidence was the 16-inch footprint Jerry Crew found, plus other footprints people sighted in the woods. But later, two brothers admitted the footprints Crew found were fake. People saw clumps of fur and scat, but these could have come from other animals living in the woods. And a 1967 film that supposedly captures Bigfoot is so blurry that there is no way to tell what it actually shows. Most scientists agree the film shows a person in a costume.
  6. Based on the last section, what are some mythical creatures that turned out to be real? Why are these included in the article? (text structure) The okapi and the giant squid were both thought to be mythical creatures that only existed in tales people told. But scientists eventually discovered that these species are real. They are included in the article to show that it’s possible, although very unlikely, that a creature such as Bigfoot exists. It also explains why some people continue to believe in Bigfoot, even though there is no evidence he is real.

Critical-Thinking Question

  1. Why do you think many people believe that Bigfoot exists, even though there is no proof that he does? (analyzing) Answers will vary. Students might say that it’s fun to think that a mysterious creature could be lurking in the woods, and people don’t want to give up on this possibility. As the article points out, no one has said that Bigfoot is dangerous, so people might like the idea of a “gentle giant.” Also, many species have not yet been discovered, and perhaps Bigfoot is one of them. 
  2. Based on what you read here, what do you think is important to consider in deciding whether something is true? (critical thinking) It is important to consider what the evidence shows and what experts, such as scientists, say. It is also important to think about the evidence and whether it could be a hoax. The footprints Crew found turned out to be planted as a joke. The film that supposedly showed Bigfoot was too blurry to truly be used to prove anything. The newspaper article that Andrew Genzoli wrote was supposed to be just for fun; he didn’t think people would actually believe it.
  3. The author ends, “And if someone does prove that this gentle giant is out there? Maybe it would be best if we humans left him alone.” Why do you think she says this? Do you agree? (author’s purpose) The author probably says this to show that no harm has ever come from this supposed giant creature; he hasn’t bothered humans, so we shouldn’t bother him. Answers will vary for the second question. 

3. SEL Focus

Open-Mindedness 

 

This article explains how something that many people believed turned out to be a hoax. This provides a perfect springboard to talk about changing your mind when new evidence is presented. Discuss this with your class, then ask:

How do you think Jerry Crew and others who thought Bigfoot was real might have responded when the “evidence” they relied upon, like the footprints, was shown to be fake? When might it be important to be open to changing your mind? Answers will vary. Students might say that Crew was probably disappointed but perhaps accepted the new evidence. Discuss the importance of evaluating evidence and taking into account what is proved by experts. Talk about how calmly explaining your position while citing evidence, and listening respectfully to others even if you disagree with them, is an important part of having productive conversations. 

4. Skill Building and Writing

  • Distribute or assign the Text Evidence Skill Builder (available in your Resources tab), which will prepare students to respond to the writing prompt at the end of the article. 
  • Have students complete the Research Kit (available in your Resources tab) for this article about mythical creatures. It can be done independently or in pairs. The Online Research Helper at the end provides factors to consider in deciding whether information students find online is reliable.

Great Ideas for Remote Learning

  • In your virtual classroom, share the Presentation View of the article on your screen. Have volunteers read sections of the article aloud, then pause to discuss the most important ideas and details from the section. 
  • Have students create a picture book about Bigfoot, based on what they read in the article. When you meet in your virtual classroom, students can share their work with the class. 

Differentiate and Customize
For Struggling Readers

Work together with students in a small group. As you read the article, prompt students to use one color to highlight text evidence that shows why some people have believed Bigfoot exists, and use another color to highlight text evidence that shows why his existence is highly unlikely. Encourage them to look at the captions as well. Remote-learning tip: When students read the articles online in Presentation View, they can use the highlighter tool to mark the text.

For Advanced Readers

Review the section “Bigfoot Is Born” and what tall tales are. Then invite students to write their own just-for-fun tall tales about seeing Bigfoot in your hometown! Consider having them make an audio recording of their tale to share with the class. 

For ELL Students

Have students read or listen to the lower-Lexile version of the article. Then assign the Questions for English Language Learners activity, which is now student-facing! You can share it with students digitally as an interactive activity or print out a pdf to distribute or include in a packet.

Text-to-Speech