two elephants standing in front of a stone wall
Anja Nachtweide/EyeEm/Getty Images

Should These Elephants be in a Zoo?

Wild animals have been kept in zoos for thousands of years. But is it time to set them free?

By Talia Cowen
From the May/June 2021 Issue
Lexile: 600L-700L, 800L-900L
Guided Reading Level: T
Download and Print

Shutterstock.com

 

Monkeys swing from branches above. Baby leopards tumble in tall grass. Squawks from colorful birds echo through the trees. You might think you’re in the forests of Tanzania. But then you spot a group of kids pointing at the animals through a glass wall. Yup, you’re in a zoo.

Zoos have existed for thousands of years. In ancient Egypt, rulers collected wild animals and showed them off at their palaces. It wasn’t until the 1800s, though, that public zoos opened, and the average person could see dazzling creatures up close. People were wowed. But the animals were squeezed into tiny cages. They were seen more as entertainment than as living creatures.

Today in the U.S., there are laws to make sure that zoo animals are comfortable and well cared for. More and more zoo animals live in large, open areas that are similar to their natural habitats. And while zoos are still a source of entertainment, many also help protect animals and teach people about them.

But even with all the improvements, some people wonder: Is it OK to keep animals in zoos?

Monkeys swing from branches above. Baby leopards tumble in tall grass. Squawks from colorful birds echo through the trees. Maybe you think you’re in the forests of Tanzania. But then you spot a group of kids. They’re pointing at the animals through a glass wall. Yup, you’re in a zoo.

Zoos have existed for thousands of years. In ancient Egypt, rulers collected wild animals. They showed them off at their palaces. The first public zoos opened in the 1800s. There, the average person could see dazzling creatures up close. People were wowed. But the animals were squeezed into tiny cages. They were seen more as entertainment than as living creatures.

Today in the U.S., laws help make sure that zoo animals are comfortable and well cared for. More and more zoo animals live in large, open areas. These spaces are similar to their natural habitats. Zoos are still a source of entertainment. But many zoos also help protect animals. And they teach people about them.

These are all improvements. But some people still wonder: Is it OK to keep animals in zoos?

Bored and Unhappy

Shutterstock.com

 

The reality is that life in a zoo is different from life in the wild. For one, animals have more room to roam in nature than in any zoo. To give a polar bear the space that it has in the wild, its enclosure would have to be bigger than the state of West Virginia!

And in zoos, animals must sometimes interact with each other differently than they would in nature. For example, wild elephants like to live in large, close-knit groups. In some zoos, they’re forced to live in pairs—or alone.

Living in these kinds of conditions can be harmful to animals. Some zoo creatures show signs of being bored and unhappy.

“When you see a tiger pacing back and forth, that is a very stressed tiger,” says Lori Marino, a scientist who studies animal behavior. Many people who oppose zoos argue that they’re not worth the suffering they cause.

Life in a zoo is different from life in the wild. For one, animals have more space in nature than in any zoo. In the wild, a polar bear moves around an area bigger than the state of West Virginia. Its zoo habitat is much smaller than that!

In zoos, animals must sometimes interact with each other differently than they would in nature. For example, wild elephants like to live in large, close-knit groups. In some zoos, they’re forced to live in pairs—or alone.

Living like this can be harmful to animals. Some zoo creatures appear bored and unhappy. “When you see a tiger pacing back and forth, that is a very stressed tiger,” says scientist Lori Marino. She studies animal behavior. Many people who oppose zoos argue that they cause too much suffering.

Protecting Wildlife

Shutterstock.com

 

But supporters say that zoos help animals, not hurt them. The best zoos do all they can to make enclosures feel (and smell) like home. The St. Louis Zoo uses spices, perfumes, and even poop to imitate the smells of an animal’s natural habitat.

For some animals, zoos are safer than the wild, where they face dangers like hunters, climate change, and disease. That’s especially important for animals that are endangered, or at risk of dying out. Zoos have saved creatures like the black-footed ferret and the California condor from becoming extinct.

Finally, zoos are an important place for research and education. They let scientists study animals that they can’t approach in the wild. And for visitors, seeing and learning about these amazing creatures can inspire them to help protect wildlife.

So the debate continues: Should animals stay in zoos, or do they belong in the wild?

But supporters say that zoos help animals. The best zoos do all they can to make enclosures feel—and smell—like home. The St. Louis Zoo uses spices, perfumes, and even poop to imitate the smells of an animal’s natural habitat.

For some animals, zoos are safer than the wild. There, animals face dangers like hunters, climate change, and disease. Zoos are especially important for endangered animals. These animals are at risk of dying out. Zoos have saved creatures like the black-footed ferret and the California condor from becoming extinct.

Finally, zoos are an important place for research and education. They let scientists study animals that they can’t approach in the wild. They also let visitors see and learn about these amazing creatures. That can inspire people to help protect wildlife.

So the debate continues. Should animals stay in zoos? Or do they belong in the wild?

This article was originally published in the May/June 2021 issue.

This article was originally published in the May/June 2021 issue.

video (1)
Audio ()
Activities (4)
Quizzes (1)
Answer Key (1)
video (1)
Audio ()
Activities (4) Download All Activities
Quizzes (1)
Answer Key (1)

More About the Story

Complexity Factors

Purpose

The debate presents arguments for and against keeping wild animals in zoos.

Structure

The text begins with a you-are-there scenario and gives a brief history of zoos. This is followed by a section that presents reasons against zoos and another in support of zoos.

Language

The language is mainly conversational but includes a few challenging words, such as habitat and enclosure, as well as rhetorical questions.

Knowledge Demands 

The article mentions Tanzania, ancient Egypt, and climate change.

Step-by-Step Lesson Plan

1. Preparing to Read

Have students preview the text features. Ask:

  • What is the topic of the debate? (Prompt students to use the debate title and the heading on the chart as clues.)
  • What do you think are the two sides of the issue?

2. Reading the Debate 

Read the debate as a class or in small groups.  A lower-Lexile version is available on Storyworks Digital. 

Have students read the debate a second time. Prompt them to mark the types of support the author presents to back up each side, including:

  • Facts and statistics (F/S)
  • Quotes from experts (Q)
  • Stories or examples (EX)

3. Discussing

As a class or in groups, have students discuss:

  • Which evidence is most effective in supporting each side?
  • Is one side stronger than the other? Why?
  • What is your opinion? What evidence do you find the most convincing?
  • For more-advanced students: Do you think the author has a preferred point of view on this issue? What is your evidence?

4. Writing

Have students complete the chart in the magazine.

Distribute the activity “Write an Opinion Essay.” The lower-level version guides students to write a three-paragraph essay on the debate topic. The higher-level version prompts them to bring in additional evidence and write six paragraphs, including a rebuttal of the other side. With either version, hand out our Opinion Writing Toolkit, which offers writing tips and transition words.

Text-to-Speech