Article
IgorZh/Shutterstock.com

Are Those Aliens?

For years, people have seen strange objects in the sky. What exactly are they?

By Kristin Lewis
From the February 2022 Issue

Learning Objective: Students will identify reasons and evidence in an article about UFOs to explain what these flying objects might be. They will also consider evidence to decide whether they think aliens exist.

Lexile: 600L-700L, 800L-900L
Guided Reading Level: T
DRA Level: 50
Other Key Skills: reasons and evidence, text evidence, key details, inference, text structure, analyzing, formulating ideas, explanatory writing
Download and Print
UP CLOSE: Reasons and Evidence

As you read, look for evidence the author includes to explain what UFOs might be—and whether aliens exist.

It was a bright June day in 1947, and pilot Kenneth Arnold was flying over beautiful snow-capped mountains. He was on his way to Oregon, but he had decided to head off course to Mount Rainier in Washington State. A military plane was thought to have crashed there. A reward was being offered to the first person who found it.

Arnold never did find the downed plane. But he did find something else.

Something so extraordinary that it would forever change the course of his life—and American history.

Something he would come to believe was not of this Earth.

That’s right. We’re talking about aliens.

It was a bright day in 1947. Pilot Kenneth Arnold was flying toward Mount Rainier in Washington State. A plane might have crashed there. The first person to find it would get a reward.

Arnold never found the plane. But he did find something else.

It was something so unbelievable that it would forever change his life—and American history.

It was something that he later believed was not of this Earth.

That’s right. We’re talking about aliens.

The Mystery

The Mystery

As he got close to Mount Rainier, Arnold saw nine strange objects in the sky. At first, he thought they might be a flock of birds. But that couldn’t be. The objects had shiny surfaces, and sunlight sparkled off them. Were they planes? Unlikely. The objects didn’t seem to have pilots, though they sometimes darted and flipped.

Even crazier, the objects were traveling at 1,200 miles per hour or more, according to Arnold. At that speed, you could cross five football fields in about one second! Nothing flew that fast, Arnold knew—and certainly not birds. He was puzzled. If only he had a camera with him, he thought.

After he landed, Arnold told his story to other pilots and a reporter. On June 25, the East Oregonian newspaper ran a front-page article about Arnold’s story. According to the article, the flying objects Arnold saw were “saucer-like.” (Saucers are small, round plates.)

“It seemed impossible,” Arnold said in the article. “But there it is—I must believe my eyes.”

The story was quickly picked up by other newspapers. And it sparked a frenzy. What had Arnold seen? Could it have been some kind of military test? A weapon? Or was it something stranger? Was it aliens?

Whatever it was, the public became obsessed. Within a month, people reported seeing more than 850 unidentified flying objects—or UFOs.

Arnold saw nine strange objects in the sky. At first, he thought they were birds. But that couldn’t be. The objects were shiny. Sunlight sparkled off them. Were they planes? Unlikely. The objects didn’t seem to have pilots. But sometimes, they darted and flipped.

Even crazier, the objects were traveling at 1,200 miles per hour or more. At that speed, you could cross five football fields in about one second! Arnold knew that nothing flew that fast—and certainly not birds. He was puzzled. If only he had a camera with him, he thought.

After he landed, Arnold told his story to other people. A newspaper ran an article about his story. According to the article, the flying objects Arnold saw were “saucer-like.” (Saucers are small, round plates.)

“It seemed impossible,” Arnold said in the article. “But there it is—I must believe my eyes.”

The story was quickly shared by other newspapers. And it sparked an uproar. What had Arnold seen? Could it have been a weapon? Or was it something stranger? Was it aliens?

People became obsessed. Soon, they reported seeing more than 850 unidentified flying objects—or UFOs.

Shutterstock.com

SAY HELLO TO ALIENS!

After Kenneth Arnold (who was from Idaho) spotted strange flying objects in 1947, there was an explosion of similar reports, especially in the Southwest.

What’s Out There?

What’s Out There?

For as long as humans have walked on Earth, we have gazed up at the sky and wondered what might be out there. And we’ve told stories to try to explain what we don’t yet understand.

Early humans saw the shapes of great and powerful beings in the night sky. Now we know those shapes are stars and planets.

In the 1400s, hundreds of people in Nuremberg, Germany, panicked one day when they saw flying globes battle in the sky and then disappear in a puff of smoke. Historians now believe this was most likely a natural event called a sun dog. It happens when ice crystals in the clouds cause bright spots to appear in the sky on either side of the sun.

In the late 1800s, scientists observing Mars through their telescopes saw straight lines on the surface of the planet. Some concluded the lines were waterways built by an advanced civilization of martians. Today, we know what they saw was likely a trick of the eye—or perhaps dust storms.

By the time Arnold flew over Mount Rainier in 1947, there was real fear that aliens could invade Earth. In fact, just nine years earlier, some people believed that martians were attacking New Jersey. They had been listening to a radio play based on the novel The War of the Worlds by H.G. Wells. But some listeners mistakenly believed an alien invasion was actually happening.

Humans have always looked up at the sky and wondered what might be out there. And we’ve told stories to try to explain what we don’t yet understand.

Early humans saw the shapes of great and powerful beings in the night sky. Now we know those shapes are stars and planets.

In the 1400s, hundreds of people in Germany were scared by flying globes that disappeared in a puff of smoke. Experts now believe this was most likely a natural event called a sun dog. It happens when bits of ice in the clouds cause bright spots to appear in the sky next to the sun.

In the late 1800s, scientists were looking at Mars through their telescopes. They saw straight lines on the planet. Some concluded the lines were waterways built by a civilization of martians. Today, we know what they saw was likely a trick of the eye. Or maybe it was dust storms.

By 1947, there was real fear that aliens could attack Earth. In fact, just nine years earlier, some people believed that martians were attacking New Jersey. They had been listening to a radio play. It was based on the novel The War of the Worlds by H.G. Wells. But some people thought an alien attack was actually happening.

PATRICK T. FALLON/AFP via Getty Images

Today, aliens are a big tourist attraction in the Southwest. There are alien-themed shops, restaurants, museums, and festivals.

UFO Mania

UFO Mania

In the years after Arnold’s story made headlines, the number of UFO reports exploded. Farmers saw strange lights over their fields. Kids stargazing in their backyards spotted flying saucers high in the air.

And after a mysterious object was found in the desert near Roswell, New Mexico, rumors spread that aliens had crash-landed there. (An official report stated that a weather balloon—not a spaceship—had crashed near Roswell.)

UFO hunting became a national hobby. People formed clubs to discuss UFO reports. Some of the most popular sci-fi movies and TV shows featured aliens in flying saucers. Sometimes these aliens were sweet. Sometimes they were terrifying.

Meanwhile, the mystery remained: What were people seeing? As with the lines on Mars, was there a simple explanation? Or could it really be aliens?

Soon, people started seeing more and more UFOs. Farmers saw strange lights over their fields. Kids spotted flying saucers high in the air.

And a strange object was found in the desert near Roswell, New Mexico. Rumors spread that aliens had crashed there. (An official report said that a weather balloon—not a spaceship—had crashed near Roswell.)

UFO hunting became a hobby. People formed clubs to discuss UFO reports. Some of the most popular sci-fi movies and TV shows featured aliens. Sometimes these aliens were sweet. Sometimes they were terrifying.

Meanwhile, the mystery remained: What were people seeing? Was there a simple explanation? Or could it really be aliens?

Spy Planes

Spy Planes

As thrilling as that would be, the answer is: probably not.

After 1945, the U.S. military was secretly testing many new types of planes. Some could fly without pilots or fly in ways no one had seen before. The A-12 spy plane, for example, could fly faster and higher than anything before it.

Many of these tests took place near a secret military base called Area 51, in a remote part of Nevada. That likely explains why many UFO reports came from the Southwest, not far from Area 51.

In fact, if you lived in the Southwest back then, you might have spotted a UFO too!

As exciting as that would be, the answer is: probably not.

After 1945, the U.S. military was secretly testing many new types of planes. Some could fly without pilots. Some could fly in ways no one had seen before. The A-12 spy plane, for example, could fly faster and higher than anything before it.

Many of these tests took place near a secret base called Area 51 in Nevada. That likely explains why many UFOs were seen in the Southwest. That’s where Area 51 is.

If you lived in the Southwest back then, you might have seen a UFO too!

MERVYN REES/Alamy Stock Photo

PLANE OR FLYING SAUCER?

Spy planes like this Lockheed A-12 were top secret. You can see from the plane’s shape that when it was up in the air, it could have been mistaken for a flying saucer.

UFOs Today

UFOs Today

Over the years, details about the secret planes have been made public. Today, experts believe that many UFOs were probably test flights for those planes. Yet UFO reports have continued to this day.

Recently, a group of government officials came together to look into UFO reports from 2004 to 2021. And last summer, this group released its findings. Overall, 144 UFO incidents were analyzed. Many are deeply puzzling. Some are eerily similar to what Arnold saw back in 1947.

In one incident, for example, Navy pilots said that spinning objects appeared at about 30,000 feet over the East Coast. The objects didn’t seem to have engines. How were they flying? Where was their fuel? They were seen almost every day from the summer of 2014 to March 2015.

In the end, the government group concluded that we don’t have enough information to fully understand what every UFO might be. The report did not mention anything about aliens. But it didn’t rule them out either.

Maybe some UFOs are no more than birds or balloons or a drone from someone’s backyard. Maybe they are just light filtering through the clouds—a trick our eyes are playing on us. Maybe, like spy planes from years ago, they are a new technology that most people don’t know about yet.

One thing remains clear: Many of us want to believe in aliens. In fact, 4 in 10 Americans believe UFOs are extraterrestrial, or from outside our planet.

Yet believing something to be true and it being true aren’t always the same thing.

Today, experts believe that many UFOs were probably those secret planes. Yet UFO reports have continued to this day.

Recently, a group of government officials looked into UFO reports from 2004 to 2021. Overall, 144 UFOs were analyzed. Many are deeply puzzling. Some are eerily similar to what Arnold saw in 1947.

For example, Navy pilots saw spinning objects at about 30,000 feet over the East Coast. The objects didn’t seem to have engines. How were they flying? Where was their fuel? They were seen almost every day from the summer of 2014 to March 2015.

In the end, the group concluded that we don’t have enough information to fully understand what every UFO might be. It did not say anything about aliens. But it didn’t rule them out either.

Maybe some UFOs are no more than birds or balloons. Maybe they are just a trick our eyes are playing on us. Maybe they are a new technology few people know about yet.

One thing is clear: Many of us want to believe in aliens. In fact, 4 in 10 Americans believe UFOs are extraterrestrial, or from outside our planet.

Yet believing something to be true and it being true aren’t always the same thing.

Science Photo Library - MARK GARLICK/Getty Images

EXPLORING THE UNIVERSE

The image above shows a galaxy, a very large group of stars. Scientists think that there are billions of galaxies in the universe, each with millions of stars, like our sun. Each of those stars likely has at least one planet circling it. Could those planets have life on them?

The Search

The Search

Whatever UFOs may be, many scientists do believe that there is some kind of life on other planets. We could even find it in your lifetime.

“One of the most fundamental questions that we ask ourselves is, are we alone?” says astronomer Michelle Kunimoto.

Right now, scientists like Kunimoto are searching the stars for clues. Today, telescopes can see deeper into space than ever before. We’ve sent rovers to explore the surface of Mars. (Alas, no martians were waiting to greet them.)

And it seems like a new planet is discovered almost every day. Scientists believe there could be as many as 300 million planets in our galaxy—the Milky Way—that might support life.

That life probably won’t be what we expect though.

“When people think of life, they think intelligent life like humans and animals and everything that lives on Earth,” says Kunimoto. “But it’s more likely that the first type of life we’ll find will be microorganisms like bacteria.”

Whatever UFOs may be, many scientists do believe that there is some kind of life on other planets. We could even find it in your lifetime.

“One of the most fundamental questions that we ask ourselves is, are we alone?” says astronomer Michelle Kunimoto.

Right now, scientists like Kunimoto are looking for clues. Today, telescopes can see deeper into space than ever before. We’ve sent rovers to explore Mars. (Alas, no martians were there to greet them.)

And it seems like a new planet is discovered almost every day. Scientists believe there could be millions of planets in our galaxy—the Milky Way—that might have life.

That life probably won’t be what we expect though.

“When people think of life, they think intelligent life like humans and animals and everything that lives on Earth,” says Kunimoto. “But it’s more likely that the first type of life we’ll find will be microorganisms like bacteria.”

DAVID NUNUK/SCIENCE PHOTO LIBRARY

Scientists use many tools, like this telescope, to look for alien life.

The Mystery Continues

The Mystery Continues

So what about Arnold and the strange objects he saw way back in 1947?

No official explanation exists. In an interview in 1950, Arnold gave his own view. He said he believed the objects were “of an extraterrestrial origin.”

We may never solve the mystery of what he saw that day in the bright, sunny skies over Mount Rainier. But Arnold’s story reveals a deeper truth: Human curiosity is powerful. So too is our imagination.

And whatever is waiting out there in space, it will take both to find it.

So what about Arnold and the strange objects he saw back in 1947?

No official explanation exists. In 1950, Arnold said he believed the objects were “of an extraterrestrial origin.”

We may never solve the mystery of what he saw that day in 1947. But Arnold’s story reveals a deeper truth: Human curiosity is powerful. So too is our imagination.

And whatever is waiting out there in space, it will take both to find it.

Write to Win

What are some explanations for the UFOs people have seen? Do you think aliens could be responsible for any? Answer in an essay using reasons and evidence from the article. Send it to “UFO Contest” by April 1, 2022. Five winners will each receive a $20 gift card to the Scholastic Store Online. 

Write to Win

What are some explanations for the UFOs people have seen? Do you think aliens could be responsible for any? Answer in an essay using reasons and evidence from the article. Send it to “UFO Contest” by April 1, 2022. Five winners will each receive a $20 gift card to the Scholastic Store Online. 

This article was originally published in the February 2022 issue.

This article was originally published in the February 2022 issue.

video (1)
Slideshows (2)
Slideshows (2)
Audio ()
Activities (13)
Quizzes (1)
Answer Key (2)
Answer Key (2)
video (1)
Slideshows (2)
Slideshows (2)
Audio ()
Activities (13) Download All Activities
Quizzes (1)
Answer Key (2)
Answer Key (2)
Step-by-Step Lesson Plan

Table of Contents

1. Preparing to Read

2. Reading and Discussing

SEL Focus, Close Reading, Critical Thinking

3. Skill Building and Writing

4. Digital Spotlight

5. Differentiate and Customize

Striving Readers, Advanced Readers, Multilingual Learners

6. Can’t-Miss Teaching Extras

1. Preparing to Read

Spark Engagement, Examine Text Features, Preview Vocabulary

  • Ask students: Do you think there is life beyond our planet? Why or why not? Have a class discussion, recording on the whiteboard the reasons students give for believing there is or isn’t life on other planets.
  • Have students browse through the article’s text features, looking at the pictures, captions, section headers, and sidebar. Ask: What do you think this article will explain? Why do you think that?
  • Many of the vocabulary words in this article will help students talk about life in space. Show or assign the Vocabulary Slideshow to preview the words. Then assign the Vocabulary Skill Builder before or after reading. Highlighted terms: UFOs, civilization, rumors, analyzed, eerily, extraterrestrial, astronomer, rovers, galaxy, microorganisms
  • Call on a student to read aloud the Up Close box on page 4. Remind students that a UFO is an unidentified flying object.

2. Reading and Discussing

  • Read the article together as a class, calling on different students to read each section of the article. Alternatively, you can listen to the Audio Read-Aloud together. Make sure you read the sidebar, “Aliens Through Time.”
  • Put students into small groups or pairs. Ask them to discuss or write their answers to the close-reading and critical-thinking questions. Discuss the SEL Focus together as a class after reading.

SEL Focus

Curiosity

Together, reread astronomer Michelle Kunimoto’s quote: “One of the most fundamental questions that we ask ourselves is, are we alone?” Ask: Why do you think people wonder if we’re alone in the universe? (Because people are curious and want to learn as much as they can about the universe. They’re also fascinated by and a little scared of the unknown.) Have students reflect on what they wonder about the universe and life on other planets, and how it makes them feel.

Close-Reading Questions

  • Reread the first section of the story on page 5 and the section “The Mystery.” What made pilot Kenneth Arnold believe that what he saw “was not of this Earth”? (text evidence) The nine objects had shiny surfaces and were flying at 1,200 miles per hour or more—faster than any bird or known technology at the time. The objects were “saucer-like” and didn’t have any pilots, even though they moved through the air as if they did.
  • What evidence does the author include in the section “What’s Out There?” to explain some strange things people have seen through time? (text evidence) The “shapes of great and powerful beings” that early humans saw in the night sky were constellations of stars and planets. Flying globes seen in Germany in the 1400s were likely a natural event called a sun dog. And lines seen on the surface of Mars were either a trick of the eye or dust storms.
  • Reread the sections “UFO Mania” and “Spy Planes.” What are some of the UFOs people reported after 1947? How can these UFOs be explained? (key details/text evidence) Farmers saw strange lights over their fields. Kids saw flying saucers high in the sky. And a strange object was found near Roswell, New Mexico. An official report said the strange object found near Roswell was a weather balloon that had crashed, not a spaceship. The other flying objects were likely secret spy planes that the U.S. military was testing at the time.
  • How does the sidebar “Aliens Through Time” support the idea that people are fascinated by aliens? (text features) The sidebar shows how aliens have been depicted in popular media from 1898 to today. Sometimes the aliens are evil and invade Earth. Sometimes they are sweet and lovable. The fact that so many books, movies, shows, and video games feature aliens shows how much people love reading and watching stories about aliens.
  • Why do you think the group of government officials didn’t rule out that some UFOs could be extraterrestrial? (inference) The government group didn’t rule out that aliens may be behind some UFOs because we don’t have enough information to really explain every single UFO incident. If we can’t prove that a UFO was actually a human aircraft or something else, like a natural event, that means there is a possibility that the UFO came from outside our planet.
  • According to the section “The Search,” what kind of life do scientists expect to find on other planets? How are they looking for it? (text evidence) Scientists expect to find tiny organisms like bacteria on other planets, rather than complex life like animals. Scientists use many tools, like telescopes and rovers, to look for life in the universe.
  • How does the section “The Mystery Continues” connect with the beginning of the story? (text structure) The first section of the story opens with pilot Kenneth Arnold flying toward Mount Rainier in Washington State and seeing some strange objects in the sky. The section “The Mystery Continues” goes back to what Arnold saw and explains that no official explanation was ever given for the incident, but Arnold thought the objects were extraterrestrial.

 

Critical-Thinking Questions

  • The author says that “Many of us want to believe in aliens. In fact, 4 in 10 Americans believe UFOs are extraterrestrial . . .” Why do you think many people believe that aliens exist? (analyzing) Answers will vary. Students might say that it’s fun to think that other life forms exist in the universe. As the article points out, experts can’t explain what every UFO might be. Plus, the universe is so big that we can’t possibly explore every corner of it. So there could be aliens living on planets that are too far for us to study.
  • Consider everything you learned in the article about UFOs and the search for alien life. Do you think there is life beyond our planet? Use reasons and evidence from the article in your answer. (formulating ideas/reasons and evidence) Answers will vary.

3. Skill Building and Writing

  • Distribute the Finding the Evidence Skill Builder (available in higher and lower levels), or assign the Slide Deck.
  • As a class, read the writing prompt in the Write to Win box on page 9. Have students use their completed Reasons and Evidence Skill Builder to help them respond to the prompt. Then you can send their essays to our writing contest (see page 2 for details)!

4. Digital Spotlight

  • In our video “Beyond the Story: Are Those Aliens?,” astronomer Michelle Kunimoto discusses how scientists are looking for extraterrestrial life and what that life might be like. Watch the video as a class after reading the article, then have students complete the Video Discussion Questions.

Differentiate and Customize
For Striving Readers

Share the lower-level version of the article (available online, also as a printable PDF) with students and make sure they follow along as they listen to the lower-level audio read-aloud of the article.

For Advanced Readers

Have students work in groups or pairs to write a newspaper article about any of the UFO incidents mentioned in the story. The articles should include a headline, subhead, and an illustration of the UFO.

For Multilingual Learners

Assess reading comprehension by having students answer the Questions for Multilingual Learners (available as a printable PDF or interactive slide deck) instead of the Close-Reading and Critical-Thinking Questions. Review the answers together as a group.

Can't-Miss Teaching Extras
Learn About Astronomy

This fun interactive article by the American Museum of Natural History will help your students learn more about the universe and how scientists study it.

Make a Science Connection

Share this article from our friends at SuperScience with your students. It’s all about how scientists are looking for life within our solar system.

Explore Our Galaxy and Beyond

Let your young space enthusiasts explore the universe, learning fun facts and going on space explorations at this NASA Science site.

Imagine Aliens

If there are aliens out there, what might they be like? In this article from The Conversation, a real scientist answers one curious kid’s question about life in space.

Text-to-Speech